I went to the pharmacy to pick up my prescriptions, which feels slightly inconsistent with the number of push-ups I can still do.
I am a fit man in his mid-50s. Good cholesterol. Normal blood pressure. I try to eat clean. And yet the pharmacist leaned in and asked, in the tone of someone announcing a gas leak:
“Are you up to date on your measles vaccine? There are over a thousand cases in Georgia.”
There are not over a thousand cases in Georgia.
There have been thousands of cases nationally over the past year as measles has resurged across multiple states. Georgia has had cases. Georgia is not descending into a sepia-toned fever dream.
Still. The fact that this sentence exists.
We Already Had This Conversation in 2000
Measles was declared eliminated in the United States in 2000. We did it. We solved it. We had the parade. We put it in the drawer labeled “Handled.”
Eliminated meant it was no longer spreading continuously here because enough people were vaccinated. Around 95 percent coverage prevents outbreaks. Below that, especially in tight-knit communities, measles does what it has always done.
It spreads like gossip at a wedding that was quietly moved up six months for “logistical reasons.”
Measles is not nostalgic. Before the vaccine, millions of Americans caught it every year. Hundreds died annually in the United States. Globally, it still kills more than 100,000 people a year, mostly unvaccinated children. In developed countries, about one to three out of every thousand infected children die. Others suffer pneumonia or brain inflammation that can leave permanent damage.
We dramatically reduced that with a vaccine introduced in the 1960s that is about 97 percent effective after two doses.
This was not a close call. It was a clean win.
Then we decided competence was suspicious.
The Cabinet Phase of Vaccine Skepticism
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., now Secretary of Health and Human Services, built much of his public profile amplifying vaccine skepticism, including repeating claims about vaccines and autism that have been thoroughly studied and repeatedly debunked. The scientific consensus on that question has not budged.
Once in office, he removed the entire membership of the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. That is the independent group of scientists who review safety data, analyze outbreak trends, and set the vaccine schedule pediatricians follow nationwide. Clearing that table did not just change personnel. It interrupted a decades-long process designed specifically to keep politics out of immunization policy.
You do not need a conspiracy to get consequences. When institutional guardrails loosen, public confidence erodes. When confidence erodes, vaccination rates dip. When rates dip below herd immunity thresholds, measles does math.
Viruses do not care about culture wars.
The Amnesia
Vaccines worked so well that we forgot what they prevented.
Most of us have never seen a child hospitalized with measles pneumonia. We do not remember parents sitting through encephalitis scares. We do not remember that before the vaccine, infection in childhood was nearly universal.
When something disappears from daily life, it starts to feel optional. The disease becomes theoretical. The shot becomes ideological. The algorithm does the rest.
We can livestream from space but struggle to keep kindergarten vaccination rates above 95 percent.
That is not a scientific problem. It is a cultural one.
The Actual Prick
I checked my records.
I was due for a second MMR dose.
So I got it.
Now my left tricep throbs like it did an aggressive OrangeTheory class it did not consent to. But that feels preferable to pneumonia, encephalitis, or becoming a footnote in a public health regression.
If you have documentation of two doses or lab evidence of immunity, you are likely fine. If you are unsure, there is no harm in receiving another dose.
This is not submission. It is maintenance.
What fascinates me is how loaded that maintenance has become. A vaccine used to be routine civic upkeep. Now it feels like a personality test.
Are you independent or indoctrinated?
Are you awake or obedient?
Meanwhile, measles is just contagious.
The Sequel Nobody Needed
We eradicated endemic measles in this country a quarter century ago. Bringing it back is not bold. It is not rebellious. It is not freedom.
It is forgetting we already solved the problem.
So yes, my tricep aches, but it’s worth it.
Immunity requires memory.


Hey Rabbi Josh, I would love you to write some kind of remembrance of Jesse Jackson who died yesterday. I have noticed in conversation that people today may have missed his time as the racial justice leader because of his long illness or perhaps never cared in the first place. Jesse Jackson had a huge influence on racial and generally social justice. I am mourning his passing. Jesse Jackson’s life and death is a big deal.